pizza places in old forge

2 min read 02-02-2025

Old Forge, Pennsylvania, isn't just a town; it's a pizza pilgrimage destination. Known throughout the region (and beyond!) for its unique, thick-crust pizza, Old Forge boasts a plethora of pizzerias, each with its own loyal following and distinct style. Choosing the "best" is subjective, of course, but this guide will help you navigate the delicious landscape and find the perfect slice (or pie!) for your taste.

Understanding Old Forge Style Pizza

Before diving into specific establishments, it's crucial to understand what sets Old Forge pizza apart. Unlike the thin-crust Neapolitan or New York-style pizzas, Old Forge pizza features a thick, rectangular crust, often described as "pan-style" or "coal-fired." This thick crust provides a unique texture and acts as a vessel for the generous toppings, typically including a flavorful tomato sauce and a blend of cheeses. The coal-fired ovens contribute a distinctive smoky char that adds another layer of flavor complexity.

Top Contenders: Old Forge Pizza Powerhouses

This isn't an exhaustive list—Old Forge has many excellent pizza places!—but it highlights some of the most popular and consistently praised establishments:

1. [Pizzeria Name 1]: A Classic Choice

[Pizzeria Name 1] is a long-standing Old Forge institution, renowned for its [mention specific characteristics, e.g., perfectly crisp crust, generous cheese blend, family atmosphere]. They've perfected the Old Forge style over decades, and their consistent quality keeps customers coming back for more. Many consider them the quintessential Old Forge pizza experience.

Specialties: [Mention specific pizzas or dishes they are known for]
Atmosphere: [Describe the atmosphere: family-friendly, lively, casual, etc.]

2. [Pizzeria Name 2]: The Coal-Fired King

[Pizzeria Name 2] emphasizes the traditional coal-fired oven method, resulting in a pizza with a distinctive smoky flavor and perfectly charred crust. Their [mention specific characteristics, e.g., sauce recipe, cheese selection] sets them apart, making it a must-try for pizza purists.

Specialties: [Mention specific pizzas or dishes they are known for]
Atmosphere: [Describe the atmosphere: family-friendly, lively, casual, etc.]

3. [Pizzeria Name 3]: A Modern Take on a Classic

While upholding the traditional Old Forge style, [Pizzeria Name 3] might offer a slightly more modern or updated take. This could manifest in [mention specific characteristics, e.g., unique topping combinations, creative crust variations, updated interior]. They cater to a slightly more modern palate while still respecting the heritage of Old Forge pizza.

Specialties: [Mention specific pizzas or dishes they are known for]
Atmosphere: [Describe the atmosphere: family-friendly, lively, casual, etc.]

Finding Your Perfect Slice: Tips for Choosing

Consider your preferences: Do you prefer a crispier crust, a more doughy interior, or a specific type of cheese? Knowing your preferences will help you narrow down your choices.
Read online reviews: Websites like Yelp and Google Reviews offer valuable insights from other pizza lovers.
Don't be afraid to try something new: Old Forge offers a variety of pizza places, each with its own unique style. Stepping outside your comfort zone might lead to a new favorite!
Check for hours and availability: Some pizzerias may have limited hours, especially during the off-season.

Beyond the Pizza: Exploring Old Forge

While pizza is the main attraction, Old Forge offers more than just delicious pies. Explore the charming downtown area, visit local shops, and soak in the unique atmosphere of this pizza-loving town.

This guide serves as a starting point for your Old Forge pizza adventure. With so many fantastic options available, you're guaranteed a memorable and delicious experience. Happy eating!